Bartholomew County arrest records live in two separate systems: court-side docket entries maintained by the Bartholomew County Circuit and Superior Courts, and booking records held by the Bartholomew County Sheriff’s Office. Court filings are searchable online through Indiana’s statewide MyCase portal at Indiana MyCase docket search. For in-person requests, the Bartholomew County Courthouse Clerk’s office runs Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., and can be reached at (812) 379-1600. The Clerk’s office doors close before the posted 4 p.m. cutoff — plan to arrive well before closing.
If someone you know was just booked tonight, our Bartholomew County inmate-search page has phone-first contact info.
If you need records outside Bartholomew County
A nationwide criminal records search may help surface records from neighboring Indiana counties — Brown, Jackson, Jennings, Decatur, and Johnson — that Bartholomew County portals do not cover, along with federal cases and records predating the MyCase online window. The preliminary scan is free; a full report requires creating an account. This tool may also help verify whether a name variant or prior address appears in records from other states where the person has lived.
Sponsored: Nationwide Criminal Background Check (we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you).
This tool is not a consumer reporting agency under the FCRA and may not be used to screen anyone for employment, housing, credit, or any other purpose covered by that law.
How to look up arrest records in Bartholomew County
“Public records shall be open for inspection and copying by any person,” reads Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act — and that principle governs how you retrieve arrest records in Bartholomew County. You have three practical pathways: online through MyCase, in person at the Courthouse Clerk’s office, and by records request to the Sheriff’s Office.
MyCase online search. Indiana’s statewide court portal covers Bartholomew County Circuit Court and Superior Court filings. Enter a last name, first name, and birth year, then filter results to Bartholomew County. MyCase shows case numbers, charges, hearing dates, and dispositions for cases in the court system. It does not show raw booking data from the jail — that lives on the Sheriff’s side. The Indiana Judicial Branch: Bartholomew County page links directly to local court resources and confirms which courts are covered.
Clerk’s office in-person or mail request. Court records not yet visible on MyCase, certified copies, and older paper-era filings require a visit or written request to the Bartholomew County Courthouse Clerk. The Clerk’s office is open Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. Call (812) 379-1600 to confirm current fees before visiting. The Clerk accepts cash or money order only — include the cause number and payment category on any mailed payment. Parking around the courthouse square can be tight; free spots are available on the surrounding streets, but plan extra time. The Clerk’s doors close before the posted cutoff, so arriving by 3:30 p.m. is advisable.
Sheriff’s Office records request. Booking records, incident reports, and body-camera footage requests go to the Bartholomew County Sheriff’s Office. Call (812) 379-1750 to ask about current procedures before visiting — appointments are suggested for most records requests. Body-camera footage specifically has its own public information request form on the Sheriff’s body camera public information request page. The Sheriff’s Office is the booking authority for the county jail; records from the Columbus Police Department (123 Washington St., Columbus, IN 47201, open Monday–Friday 8 a.m.–5 p.m.) cover arrests made by city officers and are requested separately through the Columbus Police Records Division.
IDOC lookup for state-sentenced individuals. If the person you’re researching was sentenced to an Indiana Department of Correction facility rather than the county jail, use the Indiana Department of Correction offender search. That tool covers state prison placements and is separate from the Bartholomew County jail roster.
Are Bartholomew County arrest records public?
Does an arrest in Bartholomew County automatically become a public record? Under Indiana law, the answer is generally yes — with a narrow set of exceptions that matter in practice.
Ind. Code § 5-14-3, Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act, establishes that booking records, including booking photographs, are open to public inspection. The Bartholomew County Sheriff’s Office and the Clerk of Court both operate under this framework. An arrest record does not require a conviction to be public — the booking entry exists as a government record from the moment it is created.
The exceptions are real but limited. Juvenile records are not public. A case that has been expunged under Indiana’s Second Chance Law is removed from public view — the court docket entry may still show that a case existed, but the case details are sealed and the public cannot access them. Victim-protection redactions apply in certain cases: when a court issues a protective order or finds that disclosure would endanger a victim, specific identifying details about that victim are withheld from the public copy of the record. The arrest itself remains on the docket; only the protected information is redacted. You will see a notation that redaction has occurred, but not the underlying content.
Mental health and certain diversion records carry additional confidentiality protections under separate Indiana statutes. If a case was resolved through a diversion program, the public record may be limited or unavailable depending on the program terms.
Practically speaking: if you search MyCase for a Bartholomew County case and find a case number with a sealed notation, the arrest occurred but the details are not accessible to the public. If you find nothing at all, the arrest either predates the online window, was expunged, or was a booking that never resulted in a filed case. The Bartholomew County government website includes a public records request FAQ that explains how to submit a formal request under Ind. Code § 5-14-3.
What’s in a Bartholomew County arrest record?
When you pull a Bartholomew County arrest record, what you see depends on whether you’re looking at the court-side docket or the Sheriff’s booking entry — they are different documents in different systems, and they don’t always contain the same information.
The booking record, held by the Bartholomew County Sheriff’s Office, typically includes: the booking date and time, the arresting agency (Sheriff’s Office, Columbus Police Department, or Indiana State Police), the charges as written at booking, the bond amount set at initial appearance, and the booking photograph. The booking record reflects what law enforcement documented at the time of arrest — charges may later be amended or dropped by the prosecutor.
The court docket, accessible through the MyCase portal and maintained at the Bartholomew County Courthouse, contains: the case number, the formal charges as filed by the prosecutor, all hearing dates and outcomes, the attorney of record (defense and prosecution), bond conditions, and the final disposition — guilty plea, conviction, dismissal, or acquittal. The docket is the authoritative record of what happened in court.
When a case is partially sealed under Indiana’s expungement statute, the docket entry in MyCase may still show that a case exists — the case number and the fact of a filing remain visible — but the case details, charges, and disposition are hidden from public view. A researcher will see a notation that the record is sealed; they will not see the underlying content. This is the key distinction between a sealed case and a dismissed case: a dismissed case shows the full docket including the dismissal order, while a sealed case shows only the shell.
Mugshot release practices for the Bartholomew County Sheriff’s Office are not posted in a published policy document — call the Sheriff’s Office at (812) 379-1750 to ask about current booking photo availability before making a formal request.
Body-camera footage is a separate category. The Sheriff’s body camera public information request form handles those requests independently from standard arrest record requests.
How to expunge an arrest record in Bartholomew County
Indiana’s Second Chance Law gives eligible petitioners effectively one lifetime opportunity to seal their criminal history — which makes getting the timing and eligibility right before filing genuinely important.
The controlling statute is Ind. Code § 35-38-9 (Indiana “Second Chance Law”). It covers Bartholomew County the same as every other Indiana county, and petitions must be filed in the court where the conviction occurred — or, for non-conviction records, in the county of arrest. If you have records in multiple Bartholomew County courts, Indiana requires that all petitions in the county be filed together in a single proceeding.
Arrests with no conviction. An arrest that never resulted in a conviction — including cases that were dismissed or resulted in acquittal — is the most straightforward path. A dismissal or acquittal triggers automatic expungement; the order takes effect no sooner than 60 days after the case closes. For an arrest that was never charged, you may petition to expunge the arrest record one year after the arrest date. No waiting period beyond that one year applies.
Misdemeanor convictions. A misdemeanor conviction becomes eligible for expungement five years after the date of conviction, provided you have no other convictions during that period and have satisfied all terms of the sentence. The court must grant the petition if eligibility requirements are met.
Class D and Level 6 felony convictions. These lower-level felonies are eligible eight years after the conviction date, again with a clean record and completed sentence. The court must grant a qualifying petition.
More serious felonies. A more serious felony conviction may be expunged after the later of eight years from the conviction date or three years from completing the sentence. The court has discretion on these petitions — it may grant or deny.
The most serious felonies. Certain serious felony convictions require the prosecutor’s written consent in addition to meeting the time thresholds (the later of ten years from conviction or five years from completing the sentence). Sex offenses, violent offenses, and official-misconduct offenses are excluded from the Second Chance Law entirely.
To file in Bartholomew County, prepare a verified petition and file it with the Clerk of the Bartholomew County Circuit or Superior Court at the Bartholomew County Courthouse. Call (812) 379-1600 to ask about the current filing fee and whether a fee waiver is available for indigent petitioners. The Clerk accepts cash or money order.
Petitioning to seal a record is a routine legal procedure. Many people handle straightforward non-conviction petitions without an attorney. More complex cases — multiple charges, serious felonies requiring prosecutorial consent, or records spanning multiple counties — benefit from attorney assistance. The Indiana Roll of Attorneys search and the Indiana Public Defender Council locator at Indiana Public Defender Council are the official resources for finding representation.
After expungement, law enforcement agencies retain access to the sealed record. The public does not. Background checks run through public court portals will not show the sealed case. Confirm the current statute text or ask the Clerk of Court before filing — Indiana law sets the exact timing requirements, and the one-petition rule means a premature filing can foreclose future eligibility.
| Resource | What it confirms | What it cannot confirm | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| MyCase statewide court portal | Case numbers, charges as filed, hearing dates, dispositions, attorney of record for Bartholomew County courts | Raw booking data, jail roster, records predating online window, sealed case details | Search by name and birth year; filter to Bartholomew County |
| Indiana Judicial Branch: Bartholomew County | Local court contacts, links to Clerk resources, court-specific procedural information | Individual case records (use MyCase for those) | Use to find Clerk contact details and local court rules |
| Bartholomew County Sheriff’s Office | Booking records, incident reports, body-camera footage requests, jail-related questions | Court dispositions, expungement status, records from other agencies | Call (812) 379-1750 — appointments suggested; use body cam request form for footage |
| Bartholomew County Courthouse Clerk | Certified copies of court records, older paper-era filings, expungement petition filing | Booking records, Sheriff’s Office documents | Call (812) 379-1600; arrive before 3:30 p.m.; cash or money order only |
| Indiana Department of Correction offender search | State prison placements, IDOC custody status | County jail bookings, court records, dismissed cases | Search by name at the IDOC offender search tool |
| Nationwide records search (affiliate tool above) | May surface records from neighboring counties, other states, or name variants not visible in local portals | Cannot guarantee completeness; not a substitute for official certified records | Use as a supplemental check for multi-state or multi-county research needs |
Sources used for this page, verified 2026-07-21:
- Bartholomew County official government website — county-level records, warrant FAQ, and public records request information.
- Indiana Judicial Branch: Bartholomew County — local court directory, Clerk contacts, and links to court resources.
- Indiana MyCase case records search — statewide case search covering Bartholomew County Circuit and Superior Courts.
- Bartholomew County Sheriff’s Office — booking records, body-camera request procedures, and jail information.
- Bartholomew County: How do I find out if I have a warrant out for my arrest? — county FAQ on warrant search procedures.
- Bartholomew County: How do I request public records? — county FAQ on APRA requests under Ind. Code § 5-14-3.
- Indiana Department of Correction offender search — state prison placement lookup for IDOC-sentenced individuals.
- Columbus Police Department Records Division — city arrest records for Columbus, IN; open Monday–Friday 8 a.m.–5 p.m.
- Bartholomew County Sheriff body camera public information request — form for requesting body-camera footage.
Errors or outdated information? Submit a correction — we review and update within 48 hours.
Frequently asked questions about Bartholomew County arrest records
How do I confirm what’s on my Bartholomew County arrest record?
Court-side records are searchable at no cost through MyCase — enter your name and birth year, then filter to Bartholomew County. That search shows filed charges, case numbers, and dispositions. Booking records held by the Bartholomew County Sheriff’s Office are a separate document; call (812) 379-1750 to request a copy. For certified copies of court records, contact the Bartholomew County Courthouse Clerk at (812) 379-1600 — the Clerk’s office is open Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., and accepts cash or money order for fees.
How do I get a Bartholomew County arrest record sealed or expunged?
Indiana’s expungement process is governed by Ind. Code § 35-38-9 (Indiana “Second Chance Law”). An arrest that never resulted in a conviction can be petitioned for expungement one year after the arrest date; a dismissal or acquittal triggers automatic expungement no sooner than 60 days after the case closes. A misdemeanor conviction becomes eligible five years after conviction; a Class D or Level 6 felony after eight years. File a verified petition with the Bartholomew County Courthouse Clerk — call (812) 379-1600 to confirm the current filing fee and ask about indigency waivers. Indiana allows effectively one petition per lifetime, so confirm current eligibility requirements against the statute text or with a licensed attorney before filing.
Search records by county: