Court filings for Marshall County criminal cases live in two places: the statewide MyCase public search portal maintained by the Indiana Judicial Branch, and the physical docket at the Marshall County Courthouse in Plymouth. The Indiana Judicial Branch Marshall County court records page links directly to local court contacts and case-search tools. Booking records originate with the Marshall County Sheriff’s Office, reachable through the Sheriff’s official website. Marshall County Superior Court No. 2 sits at 211 W. Madison Street, Plymouth, Indiana 46563. Plan for security screening and possible wait times when visiting the Courthouse in person.
If someone you know was just booked tonight, our Marshall County inmate-search page has phone-first contact info.
If your person has a history in other states
A Marshall County court search only returns cases filed in this county’s Circuit and Superior Courts. Records from neighboring Indiana counties, cases filed in federal court, or arrests in other states won’t appear in any local portal. A nationwide database search may help fill gaps that local portals often leave — particularly useful if the person has lived in multiple states or you want to verify your own record across every jurisdiction where you’ve resided.
Sponsored: Nationwide Criminal Background Check (we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you).
This tool is not a consumer reporting agency under the FCRA and may not be used to screen anyone for employment, housing, credit, or any other purpose covered by that law.
How to look up arrest records in Marshall County
Where do Marshall County arrest records actually live, and which system has the information you need? The answer depends on whether you want court-side case data or the Sheriff’s booking record — they’re separate systems with different fields.
MyCase public search (court-side records). The Indiana Judicial Branch publishes case records for Marshall County through the statewide MyCase portal. Search by name or case number. Results include charges filed, hearing dates, case status, and dispositions for cases in Marshall County Circuit Court and both Superior Courts. MyCase is free to search and requires no account. Note that MyCase reflects what the court has entered into its system — newly filed cases may take time to appear.
The Indiana Judicial Branch Marshall County page provides direct links to local court contacts, clerk information, and the case-search tool. Use this page to confirm current Clerk of Court contact details and hours before making an in-person visit. The Courthouse at 211 W. Madison Street, Plymouth, has metal detectors at the security entrance; allow extra time and bring a valid photo ID.
Sheriff’s Office records request (booking-side records). Arrest and booking records originate with the Marshall County Sheriff’s Office. The Sheriff’s website at Sheriffmarshallcounty is the county’s primary law-enforcement records contact. Booking records — including booking date, charges at arrest, and booking photos — are generally public under Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act. The Sheriff’s Office reports standard weekday business hours of 8:00 AM to 4:00 PM Monday through Friday, with an after-hours buzzer at the north entrance for assistance outside those hours. Confirm current hours and any records-request fee before visiting.
Indiana State Police NIBRS data. The Indiana State Police Marshall County NIBRS page publishes crime-statistics data for the county. This is aggregate public-safety data, not an individual case lookup — useful for context but not a substitute for a name-specific court or booking search.
Indiana Department of Correction inmate lookup (post-conviction transfers). Once a person is convicted and transferred from the Marshall County Jail to a state facility, the county’s own records may not reflect their current location. The Indiana Department of Correction maintains the IDOC Offender Search for tracking individuals held in state custody. Search by name or DOC number. This is the correct tool when a person has been sentenced and transferred out of Marshall County’s local jail.
Confirm numbers and hours before visiting or calling any Marshall County office, as schedules can change.
Are Marshall County arrest records public?
A booking record created in Plymouth is public by default — Indiana’s open-records framework makes that the baseline, not the exception.
Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act, Ind. Code § 5-14-3, establishes that government records — including arrest records, booking photos, and court filings — are presumptively open to any person who requests them. Marshall County records fall squarely under this framework. You don’t need to explain why you want a record or demonstrate any legal interest to request one.
That default-public status has narrow exceptions. Sealed or expunged records are removed from public view after a court grants a petition under Indiana’s Second Chance Law. Juvenile records carry separate confidentiality protections and are generally not accessible through the same channels as adult criminal records. Victim-identifying information — addresses, contact details, and certain case details in sensitive offense categories — may be redacted before a record is released. Active investigative records can also be withheld while an investigation is ongoing.
One practical note: Indiana’s public-records framework applies to Indiana records. If you’re researching someone who has lived in other states, those states operate under their own access laws. Some states restrict access to arrest records more tightly than Indiana does, and some older records predate online systems entirely. The MyCase portal and the Marshall County Sheriff’s records system only reflect activity within Indiana’s court and law-enforcement ecosystem.
Records that have been expunged under Ind. Code § 35-38-9 are treated as though the arrest or conviction did not occur for most public purposes. Law enforcement retains access, but the public record is sealed. If a MyCase search returns no results for a name you expected to find, an expungement may explain the gap — or the case may simply be filed under a different name variant or in a different county.
What’s in a Marshall County arrest record?
A Marshall County arrest record typically spans two distinct documents — the booking entry and the court docket — and each contains different fields.
The booking entry is created by the Marshall County Sheriff’s Office at the time of arrest. It records the booking date and time, the arresting agency (Sheriff, Indiana State Police, or a municipal department such as Plymouth PD), the charges as written at arrest, the arrestee’s identifying information, and the booking photo. The booking entry reflects what law enforcement alleged at the moment of arrest — charges can change substantially once a prosecutor reviews the case.
The court docket lives in MyCase and at the Marshall County Courthouse. It is the court-side record of everything that happens after charges are formally filed. At the Marshall County Courthouse, docket entries include the initial hearing date, any continuances, pretrial conference dates, and the trial or plea date. Sentencing dates and the terms of any sentence — including probation terms, fines, and any suspended portion — appear in the docket once a case resolves. If a defendant is placed on probation, the docket will reflect the probation start date and the supervising court. Attorney of record — both the prosecutor and defense counsel — is listed in the case header.
Disposition is one of the most important fields for a records-checker. A case marked “dismissed” or “acquitted” looks very different from one marked “convicted.” MyCase displays disposition status when the court has entered it, but not all cases resolve quickly. A pending case may show charges and hearing dates without a final outcome.
Booking photos for Marshall County arrests are generally public under Ind. Code § 5-14-3. For the current release policy — including whether the Sheriff posts photos online or requires a written request — contact the Marshall County Sheriff’s Office directly through Sheriffmarshallcounty.
One practical distinction: the booking entry and the court docket may not match perfectly. Charges are sometimes upgraded, downgraded, or dropped between booking and arraignment. Always check both systems for a complete picture.
How to expunge an arrest record in Marshall County
Petitioning to seal an arrest record in Marshall County is a routine legal procedure — thousands of Indiana residents file successfully each year under the state’s Second Chance Law.
Indiana handles all criminal-record relief through a single statute: Ind. Code § 35-38-9 (Indiana “Second Chance Law”). There is no separate sealing statute. The law is tiered by offense level, and the tier determines the waiting period and the court’s discretion in granting the petition.
Arrests that did not result in conviction. If you were arrested in Marshall County but the case was dismissed, you were acquitted, or charges were never filed, you can petition to expunge the arrest record one year after the arrest date. Dismissals and acquittals are expunged automatically by court order — that order takes effect no sooner than 60 days after it is entered. This is the most straightforward path and the one most records-checkers ask about.
Misdemeanor convictions. A misdemeanor conviction can be expunged five years after the date of conviction, provided you meet the eligibility criteria. The court must grant the petition if you qualify — it is not discretionary at this tier.
Class D / Level 6 felony convictions. The waiting period is eight years from the conviction date. The court must grant a qualifying petition at this tier as well.
More serious felonies. The court may grant expungement after the later of eight years from conviction or three years from completing the sentence. The most serious felonies — including those requiring the prosecutor’s written consent — have a waiting period of the later of ten years from conviction or five years from completing the sentence. Sex offenses, violent offenses, and official-misconduct offenses are excluded from expungement entirely under the current statute.
Where to file. A verified petition must be filed in the county court where the conviction occurred. For non-conviction records, file in the county of arrest — that’s Marshall County Circuit or Superior Court for arrests made here. Indiana requires that all petitions in a given county be filed together in a single filing. You cannot file piecemeal across multiple visits.
Self-petition vs. attorney-assisted filing. Indiana law does not require an attorney to file an expungement petition. Many people file successfully on their own using the petition forms available through the Indiana courts system. An attorney can be useful if your record spans multiple counties, if you have a mix of offense levels requiring careful timing, or if the prosecutor’s consent is required. Neither approach is wrong — the choice depends on the complexity of your record and your comfort with court filings. The Indiana Public Defender Council locator can help identify low-cost legal assistance, and the Indiana Roll of Attorneys search at Indiana Roll of Attorneys attorney directory lets you verify any attorney’s license status.
What changes after expungement. Once a Marshall County court grants an expungement, the public record is sealed. MyCase will no longer return the case in a public search. Law enforcement agencies retain access to sealed records. The practical effect is that the record does not appear in standard background checks run against public court data.
Indiana gives each person effectively one expungement petition per lifetime, so timing matters. Confirm the current statute text or ask the Marshall County Clerk of Court before filing — the law has been amended since its original passage, and getting the waiting period right on the first attempt is important.
| Resource | What it confirms | What it cannot confirm | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| MyCase statewide case search | Charges filed, hearing dates, sentencing dates, case disposition, attorney of record for Marshall County Circuit and Superior Court cases | Booking photos, booking-only arrests not yet charged, cases expunged or sealed, federal cases | Search by name or case number; no account required |
| Marshall County Sheriff’s Office | Booking records, booking photos, arrest date, charges at time of booking | Court dispositions, case outcomes after arraignment, IDOC transfers | Visit or contact the Sheriff’s Office during weekday business hours (8 AM–4 PM); after-hours buzzer at north entrance |
| Indiana Judicial Branch Marshall County | Local court contacts, Clerk of Court information, links to case-search tools | Real-time booking data, Sheriff records, IDOC custody status | Use to confirm Clerk hours and contact details before visiting the Courthouse |
| IDOC Offender Search | Current custody location for persons transferred to Indiana state prison facilities | Local jail holds, pre-trial detainees, cases not yet sentenced to state custody | Search by name or DOC number; use when a person has been sentenced and transferred out of Marshall County Jail |
| Indiana State Police Marshall County NIBRS data | Aggregate crime statistics reported by Marshall County law-enforcement agencies | Individual case records, booking data, court outcomes | Use for county-level crime-statistics context only; not a name-search tool |
| Nationwide database search (affiliate tool above) | May surface records from other states, neighboring counties, or name variants not visible in Indiana portals | Cannot guarantee completeness; preliminary scan only without account creation | Use to check data gaps when the person has lived outside Indiana or records predate online systems |
Sources verified 2026-07-21:
- Indiana Judicial Branch: Marshall County — local court contacts, case-search access, and Clerk of Court information for Marshall County Circuit and Superior Courts
- MyCase Indiana statewide case search — public access to court dockets, charges, hearing dates, and dispositions statewide
- Marshall County Sheriff’s Office — booking records, arrest data, and law-enforcement contact for Marshall County
- Indiana State Police: Marshall County NIBRS — crime-statistics data reported by Marshall County agencies
- Indiana Department of Correction Offender Search — custody status for persons transferred to IDOC state facilities
- Indiana Judicial Branch: Public Records — statewide guidance on court record access and the MyCase system
- Indiana Code — full text of Indiana statutes including Ind. Code § 5-14-3 (APRA) and Ind. Code § 35-38-9 (Second Chance Law)
- Marshall County Superior Court No. 2 — court location at 211 W. Madison Street, Plymouth, Indiana 46563
- Indiana Public Defender Council — locator for low-cost legal assistance with expungement petitions
- Indiana Roll of Attorneys — verify attorney license status for expungement representation
Found an error or outdated detail? Submit a correction — we review and update within 48 hours.
Frequently asked questions about Marshall County arrest records
What charges show up on a Marshall County arrest record, and where do I find them?
Charges appear in two places. The booking entry — held by the Marshall County Sheriff’s Office — lists what law enforcement alleged at the time of arrest. The court docket in MyCase shows the charges as formally filed by the prosecutor, which may differ from the booking charges. Search MyCase by the person’s full name to pull up the case; the docket header shows the case number, charges, and the current status. If the case has resolved, the disposition — dismissed, acquitted, or convicted — appears in the same record. For cases still pending, you’ll see scheduled hearing dates but no final outcome yet.
How do I get a Marshall County arrest record expunged under Indiana law?
Indiana’s expungement process runs through Ind. Code § 35-38-9 (the Second Chance Law). For an arrest that didn’t result in conviction, you can petition one year after the arrest date; dismissals and acquittals are expunged automatically by court order (effective no sooner than 60 days after entry). For a misdemeanor conviction, the waiting period is five years from conviction; for a Class D or Level 6 felony, eight years. File a verified petition at the Marshall County Circuit or Superior Court — the court where the conviction occurred, or the county of arrest for non-conviction records. Indiana requires all petitions in a given county to be filed together in one submission. You may file without an attorney, or use the Indiana Public Defender Council locator to find low-cost legal help. Because Indiana allows effectively one lifetime petition, confirm current eligibility requirements with the Marshall County Clerk of Court or review the current statute text before filing.
Search records by county: