Marshall County court records live in two places: the Indiana Judicial Branch Marshall County records portal, which links directly to the statewide MyCase case-search system, and the physical files held by the Marshall County Clerk of Court at the Marshall County Courthouse in Plymouth. Pull up MyCase and search by name or case number — no account required for public case data. Marshall County Superior Court No. 2 sits at 211 W. Madison Street, Plymouth, Indiana 46563. Plan for wait times at the courthouse; metal detectors are in use at the security entrance, and building doors may be locked after 8 PM.
If someone you know was just booked tonight, our Marshall County inmate-search page has phone-first contact info.
If your person has a history in other states
MyCase covers Marshall County and Indiana’s other 91 counties well, but it won’t surface records from Illinois, Michigan, Ohio, or any other state — and it won’t show federal cases or arrests that predate the portal’s online window. A nationwide third-party search may help fill gaps that local portals often leave, including name variants or records from prior addresses in other states. The preliminary scan is free; a full report requires creating an account.
Sponsored: Nationwide Criminal Background Check (we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you).
This tool is not a consumer reporting agency under the FCRA and may not be used to screen anyone for employment, housing, credit, or any other purpose covered by that law.
How to look up arrest records in Marshall County
What’s the fastest path to a Marshall County arrest record — and which system actually has what you need? The answer depends on whether the case is still in the county jail, has moved through the courts, or resulted in a state prison sentence.
MyCase — court-side records online. The Indiana Judicial Branch Marshall County records portal routes you directly into the statewide MyCase system. Search by name, case number, or attorney. MyCase shows case filings, hearing dates, charges, and dispositions for cases in Marshall County Circuit Court and both Superior Courts. It’s the cleanest path for anything that has been formally charged and docketed. New bookings can take time to appear after arraignment, so a very recent arrest may not yet be visible.
Marshall County Clerk of Court — in-person and written requests. The Marshall County Clerk of Court maintains the physical docket files at the Marshall County Courthouse, 211 W. Madison Street, Plymouth, IN 46563. The Clerk’s office handles certified copy requests and records not yet digitized. Call to confirm current records-request fees and weekday hours before making the trip — and budget extra time, as courthouse visits can involve significant waits.
Marshall County Sheriff — booking records. The Marshall County Sheriff’s Office books arrestees into the county jail and maintains booking records, including booking photos, which are generally open to the public under Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act. The Sheriff’s Office operates on weekday business hours, with an after-hours buzzer at the north entrance for assistance outside those hours. Bring a photo ID if you plan to visit in person.
Indiana State Police — crime statistics and NIBRS data. The Indiana State Police publishes Marshall County–specific crime and incident data through its NIBRS initiative Marshall County page. This is aggregate public-safety data, not an individual arrest lookup — but it’s useful context for researchers and journalists working with Marshall County crime patterns.
Indiana Department of Correction — post-conviction transfers. Once a person is sentenced to a state facility, the Indiana Department of Correction (IDOC) takes custody. Use the IDOC offender search tool to locate someone who has been transferred out of the Marshall County Jail to a state prison. The county jail roster won’t show them once they’ve moved; IDOC is the correct path for post-conviction location.
Are Marshall County arrest records public?
Court filings, booking records, and charging documents in Marshall County carry a default-public status under Indiana law — sealed cases, juvenile records, and certain victim-protection redactions are the narrow exceptions.
Indiana’s Access to Public Records Act, Ind. Code § 5-14-3, establishes that government records — including arrest records and booking information held by the Marshall County Sheriff’s Office — are presumptively open to any person who requests them. Booking photos fall within that default-public category. You don’t need to show a reason or prove a legal interest to request a Marshall County arrest record.
The exceptions are real but narrow. Juvenile records are confidential by statute and are not accessible through MyCase or a standard public-records request. Cases that have been expunged under Indiana’s Second Chance Law are removed from public view — the court record is sealed and the Sheriff’s booking entry is restricted. Victim names and addresses in certain offense categories may be redacted before a record is released.
One important distinction: Indiana’s open-records framework applies to Indiana records. If you’re researching someone who has lived in multiple states, the rules differ by jurisdiction. Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio each have their own access statutes, and some states restrict booking-photo release entirely. A nationwide third-party search may help surface records from those jurisdictions, though per-state completeness varies.
MyCase is the practical starting point for court-side public records in Marshall County. The Indiana Judicial Branch public records page explains what case information is and isn’t available through the statewide system.
What’s in a Marshall County arrest record?
A Marshall County arrest record typically spans two distinct documents — a booking entry on the Sheriff’s side and a court docket on the Clerk’s side — and the fields visible in each differ in important ways.
The booking entry, created by the Marshall County Sheriff’s Office at the time of arrest, contains: the arrestee’s full name and date of birth, booking date and time, arresting agency, charges as initially written by the arresting officer, bail or bond amount if set, and — in most cases — a booking photograph. The charges on the booking entry reflect what the officer wrote at the scene. They may differ from what the prosecutor ultimately files.
The court docket, accessible through MyCase via the Indiana Judicial Branch Marshall County records portal, shows what actually happened in court. Fields you’ll see there include: case number, formal charges as filed by the prosecutor, all hearing dates (initial hearing, pretrial conferences, trial or plea dates), sentencing date and sentence imposed, probation terms if applicable, attorney of record for both prosecution and defense, and the final disposition — guilty, not guilty, dismissed, or deferred. Probation terms and sentencing details are visible in the docket once the case closes.
The gap between these two systems matters. A booking entry showing a felony charge may correspond to a docket showing a reduced misdemeanor plea or an outright dismissal. Always check both sources before drawing conclusions about what a record actually shows.
For cases handled at the Marshall County Courthouse, the physical file at the Clerk’s office may contain additional documents not yet scanned into MyCase — older cases in particular. The Clerk’s office at 211 W. Madison Street, Plymouth, can confirm what’s available in paper form. Note that the Marshall County Courthouse has metal detectors at the security entrance; plan accordingly if you’re visiting in person to review physical files.
Mugshot release policy for the Marshall County Sheriff’s Office is not posted in publicly available documentation — call the Sheriff’s Office directly to confirm current practice before relying on a third-party mugshot aggregator.
How to expunge an arrest record in Marshall County
Petitioning to seal an arrest record in Marshall County is a routine legal procedure, and Indiana’s statute gives most people a clear path to do it — the question is which tier applies and whether the waiting period has run.
Indiana handles all criminal-record relief through a single statute: Ind. Code § 35-38-9 (Indiana “Second Chance Law”). There are no separate sealing and expungement tracks. The law is tiered by offense level, and the tier determines both the waiting period and whether the court must grant the petition or may exercise discretion.
Arrests without a conviction are the most straightforward. If you were arrested in Marshall County but never convicted — the case was dismissed, you were acquitted, or charges were never filed — you can petition to expunge the arrest record one year after the arrest date. A dismissal or acquittal is expunged automatically once the order takes effect, no sooner than 60 days after entry. You don’t need a conviction to have a record worth sealing.
Misdemeanor convictions can be expunged five years after the conviction date, provided you meet the eligibility criteria. The court must grant a qualifying petition — it’s not discretionary at this tier.
Class D or Level 6 felony convictions require an eight-year wait from the conviction date. Again, the court must grant a qualifying petition.
More serious felonies require the later of eight years from conviction or three years from completing the sentence. The court may grant or deny these petitions. The most serious felonies — which also require written consent from the prosecutor — require the later of ten years from conviction or five years from completing the sentence.
Sex offenses, violent offenses, and official-misconduct offenses are excluded from the Second Chance Law entirely. Confirm the current statute text or ask the Marshall County Clerk of Court before filing — the law has been amended, and getting the timing right matters because Indiana effectively allows one expungement petition per lifetime.
Where to file. The petition goes to the court where the conviction occurred — for Marshall County convictions, that means the Marshall County Circuit Court or the appropriate Superior Court at the Marshall County Courthouse, 211 W. Madison Street, Plymouth, IN 46563. For non-conviction arrests, file in the county of arrest. Indiana requires that all petitions in a given county be filed together in a single filing.
Self-petition vs. attorney-assisted filing. Indiana allows self-represented petitioners to file under the Second Chance Law, and many people do. The Clerk’s office can provide the petition form. Attorney assistance is worth considering for more complex cases — multiple charges, felony tiers requiring prosecutorial consent, or situations where the eligibility question isn’t clear-cut. Neither approach is wrong; the choice depends on the complexity of your specific record. The Indiana Roll of Attorneys search can help you find a licensed attorney in Marshall County, and the Indiana Public Defender Council can point you toward indigent defense resources if cost is a barrier.
After expungement. Once a Marshall County record is sealed, it’s removed from public view — MyCase will no longer show it, and the Sheriff’s booking entry is restricted. Law enforcement agencies retain access. The record doesn’t disappear entirely; it becomes inaccessible to the general public.
Quick-contacts: Marshall County arrest record resources
| Resource | What it confirms | What it cannot confirm | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| MyCase statewide case search | Charges filed, hearing dates, sentencing dates, probation terms, dispositions, attorney of record | Booking photos; cases not yet docketed; expunged records | Search by name or case number — no account required |
| Indiana Judicial Branch Marshall County records portal | Direct entry point to Marshall County court records and MyCase; links to local court contact info | Booking-side records; Sheriff’s Office data | Use to confirm court locations and access MyCase for Marshall County |
| Marshall County Clerk of Court — 211 W. Madison St., Plymouth, IN 46563 | Certified copies of court records; paper files not yet digitized; expungement petition filing | Booking records; IDOC inmate location | Call to confirm fees and hours before visiting; allow extra time for courthouse security |
| Marshall County Sheriff’s Office | Booking records, booking photos, jail roster for current detainees | Court dispositions; post-transfer IDOC location | Weekday business hours; after-hours buzzer at north entrance; photo ID may be required |
| IDOC offender search | Location of persons sentenced to Indiana state facilities; DOC number; facility assignment | County jail detainees; pre-conviction status | Use when a person has been transferred out of Marshall County Jail to a state prison |
| Indiana State Police Marshall County NIBRS data | Aggregate crime statistics and incident data for Marshall County | Individual arrest records; booking data; case dispositions | Use for research or journalism; not an individual record lookup |
Sources verified 2026-10-23:
- Indiana Judicial Branch: Marshall County — county-specific court records portal and MyCase access point for Marshall County Circuit and Superior Courts.
- MyCase statewide case search — Indiana’s public case-search system covering all 92 counties, including Marshall County docket entries, charges, and dispositions.
- Indiana State Police: Marshall County NIBRS initiative — aggregate crime and incident statistics for Marshall County compiled by the Indiana State Police.
- Indiana Judicial Branch: Public Records — statewide guidance on what court records are publicly accessible and how to request them.
- Indiana Department of Correction offender search — locates persons sentenced to Indiana state facilities; covers post-conviction transfers out of county jails.
- Indiana Code — full text of Indiana statutes, including Ind. Code § 5-14-3 (Access to Public Records Act) and Ind. Code § 35-38-9 (Second Chance Law).
- Indiana Roll of Attorneys search — licensed attorney locator for Marshall County and statewide.
- Indiana Public Defender Council — indigent defense resources and public defender locator for Marshall County residents.
- Marshall County Superior Court No. 2 — official county page confirming court location at 211 W. Madison Street, Plymouth, Indiana 46563.
Found an error or outdated detail? Submit a correction — we review and update within 48 hours.
Frequently asked questions: Marshall County arrest records
What charges will show up on a Marshall County arrest record, and where do I find them?
A Marshall County arrest record can show charges at two stages. The booking entry — held by the Marshall County Sheriff’s Office — reflects what the arresting officer wrote at the time of arrest. The court docket, searchable through MyCase, shows the formal charges the prosecutor actually filed, along with any amendments, plea agreements, and the final disposition. These two records often differ — a booking charge may be reduced or dropped entirely by the time the case closes. Check both sources: the Sheriff’s booking record for the arrest itself, and MyCase for what happened in court.
How do I get a Marshall County arrest record expunged under Indiana law?
Indiana’s Second Chance Law, Ind. Code § 35-38-9, governs all expungement petitions in Marshall County. If you were arrested but never convicted, you can petition one year after the arrest date; dismissals and acquittals are expunged automatically once the order takes effect (no sooner than 60 days). A misdemeanor conviction requires a five-year wait from the conviction date; a Class D or Level 6 felony requires eight years. File your verified petition at the Marshall County Courthouse, 211 W. Madison Street, Plymouth, IN 46563 — in the court where the conviction occurred, or the court of arrest for non-conviction records. Indiana requires all petitions in a given county to be filed together. You may file without an attorney, but for felony-tier cases or situations requiring prosecutorial consent, legal help is worth considering. The Indiana Roll of Attorneys search can locate licensed attorneys in Marshall County.
Search records by county: